GOP shift, 2012 to 2016
Clinton
Democratic
Franklin
St. Lawrence
+0-4.9% Republican
Essex
Jefferson
+5-9.9% Republican
Hamilton
+10% and more Republican
Lewis
Warren
Washington
Oswego
Orleans
Oneida
Niagara
Fulton
Monroe
Saratoga
Wayne
Herkimer
Onondaga
Genesee
Montgomery
Erie
Cayuga
Ontario
Schenectady
Madison
Livingston
Seneca
Rensselaer
Albany
Otsego
Cortland
Yates
Wyoming
Schoharie
Tompkins
Chenango
Columbia
Schuyler
Cattaraugus
Greene
Steuben
Delaware
Tioga
Chautauqua
Allegany
Chemung
Broome
Ulster
Dutchess
Sullivan
Putnam
Orange
Westchester
Queens
Rockland
Bronx
Suffolk
New York
Nassau
Richmond
Kings
2012
Clinton
Democratic
Franklin
St. Lawrence
Republican
Essex
Jefferson
Hamilton
Lewis
Warren
Washington
Oswego
Orleans
Oneida
Niagara
Fulton
Monroe
Saratoga
Wayne
Herkimer
Onondaga
Genesee
Montgomery
Erie
Cayuga
Ontario
Schenectady
Madison
Livingston
Seneca
Rensselaer
Albany
Otsego
Cortland
Yates
Wyoming
Schoharie
Tompkins
Chenango
Columbia
Schuyler
Cattaraugus
Greene
Steuben
Delaware
Tioga
Chautauqua
Allegany
Chemung
Broome
Ulster
Dutchess
Sullivan
Putnam
Orange
Westchester
Queens
Rockland
Bronx
Suffolk
New York
Nassau
Richmond
Kings
2016
Clinton
Democratic
Franklin
St. Lawrence
Republican
Essex
Jefferson
Hamilton
Lewis
Warren
Washington
Oswego
Orleans
Oneida
Niagara
Fulton
Monroe
Saratoga
Wayne
Herkimer
Onondaga
Genesee
Montgomery
Erie
Cayuga
Ontario
Schenectady
Madison
Livingston
Seneca
Rensselaer
Albany
Otsego
Cortland
Yates
Wyoming
Schoharie
Tompkins
Chenango
Columbia
Schuyler
Cattaraugus
Greene
Steuben
Delaware
Tioga
Chautauqua
Allegany
Chemung
Broome
Ulster
Dutchess
Sullivan
Putnam
Orange
Westchester
Queens
Rockland
Bronx
Suffolk
New York
Nassau
Richmond
Kings
GOP shift, 2012 to 2016
Democratic
+0-4.9% Republican
+5-9.9% Republican
Watertown
+10% and more
Republican
Rochester
Syracuse
Buffalo
Albany
Binghamton
New York
2012
Democratic
Republican
Watertown
Rochester
Syracuse
Buffalo
Albany
Binghamton
New York
2016
Democratic
Republican
Watertown
Rochester
Syracuse
Buffalo
Albany
Binghamton
New York
Democratic
+0-4.9% Republican
+5-9.9% Republican
Watertown
+10% and more
Republican
Rochester
Syracuse
Buffalo
Albany
Binghamton
New York
GOP shift, '12-'16
Democratic
Republican
Watertown
Rochester
Syracuse
Buffalo
Albany
Binghamton
New York
2012
Democratic
Republican
Watertown
Rochester
Syracuse
Buffalo
Albany
Binghamton
New York
2016
Source: New York State Board of Elections Peter Allen | pallen@syracuse.com